Readers +69% in 30 days.List your book free →

The Books Everyone Wants to Read and Nobody Finishes

Skriuwer Research, November 2026

Some books sit on everyone's list. But how many people who plan to read them get to the last page? We looked at the 125 most shelved books on Open Library, the free library catalogue of the Internet Archive, and compared two numbers for each book: how many readers marked it "want to read" and how many marked it "already read".

The result: for the typical book in the list, 5.2% of the readers who shelved it marked it as read. For The Art of Seduction it is 1.7%: 5,911 readers want to read it and 109 marked it as read. For Animal Farm it is 20.7%.

The 15 books readers shelve and do not finish

Share of all readers who shelved the book and marked it "already read". Lowest first.

The Art of Seduction Robert Greene1.7%
The Laws of Human Nature Robert Greene1.8%
101 Essays That Will Change The Way You Think Brianna Wiest1.8%
How to Talk to Anyone Leil Lowndes1.8%
Can We Be Strangers Again? Shrijeet Shandilya2%
The Mountain Is You Brianna Wiest2%
Icebreaker Hannah Grace2.1%
We Were Never Meant To Be Palle Vasu2.2%
The 48 Laws of Power Robert Greene2.3%
The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck Mark Manson2.3%
I Don't Love You Anymore Rithvik Singh2.5%
Ikigai Héctor García2.5%
It Starts with Us Colleen Hoover2.6%
Twisted Love Ana Huang2.6%
Can't Hurt Me David Goggins2.6%
BookWant to readAlready readRead share
The Art of Seduction5,9111091.7%
The Laws of Human Nature5,6281111.8%
101 Essays That Will Change The Way You Think3,701721.8%
How to Talk to Anyone3,431681.8%
Can We Be Strangers Again?3,436782.0%
The Mountain Is You3,036652.0%
Icebreaker9,4252152.1%
We Were Never Meant To Be3,926972.2%
The 48 Laws of Power47,9901,1992.3%
The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck32,2178012.3%
I Don't Love You Anymore9,7182802.5%
Ikigai4,8451342.5%
It Starts with Us18,2745172.6%
Twisted Love13,8333992.6%
Can't Hurt Me7,7742272.6%

Two kinds of books fill the bottom of the list: self-improvement (power, habits, how to talk to people, how to heal) and recent romance and poetry. Readers save them for later, and later rarely gets marked.

The 15 books readers do finish

Animal Farm George Orwell20.7%
Brave New World Aldous Huxley20.6%
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban J. K. Rowling20.4%
The Catcher in the Rye J. D. Salinger19.4%
The Giver Lois Lowry17.5%
Lord of the Flies William Golding16.7%
Dune Frank Herbert16.4%
Fahrenheit 451 Ray Bradbury16.3%
Dracula Bram Stoker15.9%
The Hobbit J.R.R. Tolkien15.9%
The Great Gatsby F. Scott Fitzgerald15.6%
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix J. K. Rowling15.1%
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire J. K. Rowling14.8%
Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince J. K. Rowling14.5%
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets J. K. Rowling14.1%
BookWant to readAlready readRead share
Animal Farm4,1381,17520.7%
Brave New World2,75575120.6%
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban4,4071,20920.4%
The Catcher in the Rye2,40260819.4%
The Giver2,38154517.5%
Lord of the Flies2,71256916.7%
Dune3,56775016.4%
Fahrenheit 4513,60473916.3%
Dracula2,30748015.9%
The Hobbit4,15986015.9%
The Great Gatsby2,73354615.6%
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix3,74372015.1%
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire3,98275314.8%
Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince3,10656514.5%
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets5,47797814.1%

The top of the list is the school reading list and the series people grew up with.

The 10 most wanted books

These ten books have the most "want to read" marks of all. Atomic Habits leads with 59,363 readers who want to read it and 1,770 who marked it as read.

BookWant to readAlready readRead share
Atomic Habits59,3631,7702.7%
The 48 Laws of Power47,9901,1992.3%
It Ends With Us40,6951,3633.0%
Rich Dad, Poor Dad33,5761,3453.5%
The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck32,2178012.3%
Control Your Mind and Master Your Feelings22,5267993.2%
Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone21,2921,7727.1%
Um casamento arranjado20,7756462.7%
It Starts with Us18,2745172.6%
Think and Grow Rich16,4136063.2%

The whole list in three numbers

  • 125 books, each shelved by at least 3,000 readers.
  • 60 books (48%) have a read share under 5%.
  • 12 books (10%) have a read share of 15% or more.

How we measured

  • Source: the public search data of Open Library (openlibrary.org), read on 17 November 2026.
  • We took the 1,000 works with the most reading-log entries and kept those with at least 3,000 entries, so one or two clicks cannot move a book.
  • Read share = "already read" marks divided by all reading-log entries for that work (want to read, currently reading and already read together).
  • Limits: this is what Open Library users click, not a measurement of pages read. People use the "want to read" button more than the "already read" button for every book, and Open Library also lends books, which draws readers who save a title to borrow it later. So read the shares as a comparison between books, not as the true share of readers who finish.

Data: Open Library, Internet Archive. Analysis by Skriuwer, November 2026. You may quote these numbers with a link to this page.